HomeAnn Marie LudlowNever Forget: Sheriff Robert Chody’s Cold Case Unit Hot Trails on Williamson County’s Missing and Lost

Never Forget: Sheriff Robert Chody’s Cold Case Unit Hot Trails on Williamson County’s Missing and Lost

January 10, 2018 was the 14th anniversary of Rachel Cooke’s disappearance. In 2003, at home on Christmas break from college, Rachel (then 19) went out for a run and has not been seen since. Her parents’ search received state- and nationwide attention, including being featured on “America’s Most Wanted”. Sadly, her father Robert passed away in 2014 without answers. Her mom, Janet, has continued to search and hope, and every year at this time, she creates an event or holds a public gathering to talk about and share memories of her daughter.

Rachel’s story made national news again earlier this year when new information came in that the Sheriff’s Office believed to be actionable and followed up on it. The boost of visibility also brought an increase in tips and new or renewed interviews.

Unfortunately, that lead did not pan out, but Rachel’s story was top of the news cycle for a few days and Janet was able to renew her pleas for help to a large audience. The Sheriff’s office says incidents such as those provide a boost and a new channel for information and leads that might lead to something else.

More so than new leads, Rachel’s story reminds us to be aware, to be compassionate, and to never stop trying to help because hers is just one of the many the Williamson County Sheriff’s Office is actively working to resolve.

We in the media are always quick or eager to report dramatic or sensational news, but what we have discovered, especially since the Chody administration has taken over, is that we cannot say enough about crime fighting, or hot and cold cases, because greater media coverage and social media are actually making a difference.

Sheriff Chody says, “We have four detectives actively working cases every day and people don’t realize we receive new leads every week.

“But, what we really want to know is why aren’t media folks also talking about the Ritchie case or the Wallace case? Those families are pursuing the same truth and dealing with the same loss. We want those families and everyone else to know that we have many cold cases that are a priority for our entire team.”

Chody credits the hard work of his Cold Case team, directed by Sergeant Jereme Brinkmann. “The work we do is hardly cold. The term simply means the case is more than one year old or has been passed from one detective to another without being solved.

“But the trails of Cooke, Ritchie and Wallace cases are anything but cold. We have more than 1400 leads on the Cooke case alone and we get more every day.”

Captain Tim Ryle added that he received a tip via a Facebook message just the night before, “People joke about the Sheriff’s Office tweets, but being so visible all over the web means we are also accessible to folks who may not have the courage to walk into our building. We are easy to reach now, literally at everyone’s fingertips.”

Curious, I asked Sgt. Brinkmann how is it that there is so much new information or leads to look at after so much time has passed; how could there still be a stone unturned? “People move in and out of the area, relationships change; perhaps you are more ready to talk now about someone you are no longer friends with. Many tips we get are from people who previously thought their information wasn’t important, but because we’re talking about it, they think maybe it will help after all. In some of our cases, the simple act of having a new set of eyes on a file shines a light on something that was missed, or warranted another phone call or visit that didn’t happen at that time. Perhaps investigators didn’t think it was valuable to talk to a certain person at that time, but since we haven’t solved the case yet, who knows what we missed that might connect some dots we created in the interim. We have been re-interviewing people with new and different questions, and we are gaining new insights as a result.”

Sheriff Chody has a team of reserve officers who work the cold cases every day. They follow leads and re-visit the files and witnesses as needed because even though there may not ever be a trial, families want justice and answers above all.

Sergeant Brinkmann provided the City Insider with profiles and information about cases the team works on every day. There is even one case they believe to be more than 60 years old and consists of nothing more than an unidentified male skeleton. “No case is less important than another,” Chody says. “There may no longer be anyone alive in an immediate family who knew the person, but there is always a relative or friend somewhere, wondering what happened in the past.”

Following are the Sheriff’s case summaries.

10-31-1979 “Orange Socks” Unidentified Female, Homicide
On 10-31-1979 a civilian located the body of an unidentified female in a concrete ditch on the south bound side IH-35 just north of Mile Marker 268. The female was nude except for a pair of orange socks.  The body was described as a white female in her late 20s, approximately 5’4” weighing approximately 125 lbs. She had reddish-brown hair and  hazel blue eyes. She was wearing a silver, elongated oval ring containing a white stone on her right middle finger. Autopsy results show “Orange Socks” cause of death to be asphyxia by manual strangulation. Manner of death is Homicide.

10-02-1985 Althea Lanelle Rogers, White F b. 8-12-50, Missing Person
Althea Lanelle Rogers is a White Female b. 08-12-1950, who at the time of her disappearance was 5’1” and weighed 100-105 lbs. Althea has blue eyes, sandy brown to blond hair and a large hysterectomy scar across her abdomen. Althea Rogers was last seen on 10-02-1985, by her daughter Debbie Schroen, but was not reported missing to the Williamson County Sheriff’s Office until 11-02-1985.  Althea emptied her bank account of $150.00 on 10-02-1985.  Her purse and identification were left at her house, along with a note stating, “Lanelle Rogers NO LONGER EXIST!”  It is believed she left Williamson County walking North on IH-35.

12-08-1987 George Javier Gaitan, Hispanic Male 12-18-1950, Homicide
On December 8, 1987 a civilian located the body of George Javier Gaitan lying face down in a field at the corner of Highway 620 and Cornerwood drive in Williamson County.  Autopsy results show the cause of death to be two gunshot wounds.  This case was investigated but a suspect was never identified.  Gaitan was from San Antonio Texas and believed to be in the Williamson County / Austin area on business.

3-5-1988 S.E. Ritchey White Male, b. 11-26-07, Homicide, Agg Robbery
On March 6th 1988 unknown persons assaulted and robbed S.E. Ritchey and his wife at their residence, located on County Road 112 in Williamson County.  Mr. Ritchey was rushed to the hospital where he later died due to injures he sustained during the robbery.  This investigation is currently being reviewed by four cold case investigators. Under previous administrations, it was presumed, from the facts, that murder was not the intent, but the resulting death has plagued the family for nearly two decades.

10-03-1988 Skeletal Remains, Unidentified Male, Homicide
On October 3, 1988 a citizen of Williamson County found a human skull in his yard.  The citizen contacted the Williamson County Sheriff’s Office who responded to his address.  A search of the nearby area was completed.  Several human bones were located and taken to the Travis County Medical Examiner’s office.  Travis County Medical Examiner stated the remains are that of a Hispanic Male, with black hair, in his mid-thirties, about 5’6” unknown weight. Travis County Medical Examiner said the victim had been deceased approximately six months to a year. Cause of death is unknown, manner of death is Homicide.

09-25-1989 “Corona”, Unidentified female, Homicide
On September 25th 1989 three civilians discovered the body of an unidentified female on the East frontage road of IH-35, north of exit 277.  She was wearing black pants, a “Corona” t-shirt, was in her late 20s, about 5 feet tall, weighing approximately 120lbs, with light brown hair and an appendectomy scar.  Autopsy results show the cause of death to be on gunshot to the head.  The woman had been deceased one to two weeks.

12-14-1991 Vicki Lynn Nisbett, White female, Suspected Homicide
On December 14, 1991 Vicki Nisbett never arrived at a Christmas party to meet a friend. She was reported missing and presumed dead by homicide. Her body has never been found. For 20 years, the case was considered too thin and circumstantial to prove. In 2013, the Williamson County D.A. indicted her husband, Rex, having built a case on blood evidence and witness testimony. Rex was convicted for her murder in 2014 but the ruling was reversed by an appellate court due to “reversible error” and he was released in 2017. Legally, she remains missing and the Sheriff’s office continues to search for Vicki and learn the truth about her disappearance.

06-15-1994 John Myatt, White male b. 12-04-50, Homicide
On June 15th 1994 a civilian contacted the Williamson County Sheriff’s Office in reference to a body he found near the corner of County Road 254 and County Road 255, near Georgetown Texas. The body was later identified as John Michael Myatt of Mountain Home Texas.  Due to the condition of the body, cause of death is unknown.  Manner of death is Homicide.

08-02-1994 Jessica Lee Harris, White female b. 10-25-69, Homicide
On August 2nd 1994 a civilian contacted the Williamson County Sheriff’s Office in reference to a body he found just off the roadway, approximately half of a mile north of Highway 2338 on County Road 245, near Georgetown Texas. Autopsy results show Jessica’s cause of death to be asphyxia by manual strangulation with multiple blunt force injuries of the head and face.  Manner of death is Homicide.

07-24-1998 Sharon Russ McCool, White female b. 2-20-63, Homicide
On July 24th 1998 a civilian contacted the Williamson County Sheriff’s Office in reference to a body he found at the corner of Great Oaks drive and Conchos Valley Drive near Round Rock Texas.  Autopsy results show cause of death to be blunt force trauma to the head.  Manner of death is Homicide.

03-14-1999 Sonya Wallace, Hispanic Female b. 5-4-83, Homicide

On March 14, 1999 a civilian contacted the Williamson County Sheriff’s Office in reference to a body he found just off of County Road 490 about one mile west of FM 619 near Coupland Texas. The body was identified as Sonya Wallace from Taylor Texas.  Autopsy results show Sonya’s cause of death to be blunt force trauma to the head.  Manner of death is Homicide.

01-10-2002 Rachel Louise Cooke, White female b. 5-10-82, Missing
On January 10th 2002 at about 9:30am, Rachel Cooke, 19 year old female, left her home in Georgetown Texas, to go for a run. Rachel never returned home. She was attending College in California but was home for the Christmas holiday break. On January 11, 2002 at about 3:00pm, Rachel’s parents Robert and Janet Cooke reported Rachel Missing to the Williamson County Sheriff’s Office.  Since then a dedicated and focused team of investigators have investigated over 1400 tips and continue to investigate new tips as they come in.

Whatever it takes…
Sheriff Chody says his cold case unit is all about diligence, commitment and knowing investigators will never reach a point where they know everything, until it is solved. “Just recently I was doing a public presentation,” he says. “Sgt Brinkmann was reviewing my slides and noticed a business name in a photo that had been looked at hundreds of times. No one ever called that business and we may now be closer to knowing who one unidentified victim was and giving her back some dignity.”

Chody is also proud of the progress his office has made in procedure and organization. “One thing I pledge is that no matter how long I’m in this office—whoever comes after—they will never have to backtrack or ask if something was done because we will have a record; there will be organization and they will know everything that we knew. And even though these are cold cases, I feel like it’s success every day when I get a text on Facebook or we have another partner in the FBI drop everything to help us. “

Chief Ryle adds, “It is rewarding to know that these victims’ families know we are still trying. Some cases are so old and there so little information to grasp onto but there are others with good information and things we can work on, and we do. Some cases have daily activity, some are every three or four days but we stay in constant contact with families who want answers and keep them in the loop. It is gratifying to make a call and hear the relief of a mom or a sister who thought their loved one had been forgotten.”

Every day they check and re-check the boxes, maintain continuity and connect seemingly unrelated dots, all in the name of justice and letting families know they are never forgotten.

Readers are encouraged to tweet (@SheriffChody), call (512-943-1385) or visit the Sheriff’s office with any information, no matter how small the detail may seem.

Latest comment

  • All over the US, law enforcement agencies are utilizing retired law enforcement officer to work (for FREE) to re-visit cold cases. Sheriff Chody, as soon as he took office, went to the media and gave a plea –
    he hoped some retired law enforcement officers might want to help out. They answered the call and now are WORKING these cold cases again. Kudos to the Sheriff for not being afraid to ask for help.

leave a comment